Nailing Vs Stapling Roof Shingles

Staples are the method used years ago that gave machine roofing a bad name.

Nailing vs stapling roof shingles.

Also the roofer fires off more than needed into the shingle. Au contraire pgriz but staples do have an advantage over nails. At the end of the day the placement of each nail will determine the durability of your shingles. They don t have to.

Ideal nail placement on roof shingles is limited to a very small area. The roofing nail sketch of common roof shingle nailing errors shown here is a detail from fema s asphalt shingle roofing for high wind regions 2. Proper stapling also means keeping the staple crowns horizontal or level. Research on use of staples vs nails in asphalt shingle roofs.

Staples made of at least 16 gauge galvanized steel with a minimum crown of 15 16 have been and continue to be used by some applicators to install shingles. If the nail is driven outside that area it could impair the roof and void the manufacturer s warranty. The farther off horizontal the staple is driven the closer together the staple points are and the less wood is captured between the points. Some shingles after roof traffic will cut through the upper shingle leaving an exposed nail head.

In the past roofers preferred staple guns for attaching shingles to roof sheeting. We are talking nails hand or gun. For one staples cost less than nails adding to their profit per roof. When the first strong wind blows half of the shingles off it makes life sooo much easier for the next person.

They rust they back out they don t hold and they put two holes through the roof shingle whereas a nail only one. I assume if your distributor is demoing staples they must be legal in your area though. The importance of nail placement. Staples do not hold as well as nails they have less area to hold the shingle and many times are not set right and cut the shingles.

There is a right way and a wrong way to nail a shingle to a roof. Staples are not recommended by hodges roofing and most industry organizations. Staples for shingle applications are staples recommended as fasteners for asphalt shingles. Shingles are designed to be nailed in specific locations and the nail must be driven to a certain depth.

Staples should be totally banned from the roofing industry. A hand nailer can tell better if a nail is high and will give it another hit. Staples also offered excellent holding strength and could be installed over a larger roof area quickly. Make no mistake we are in business to make money.

As with nails overdriven staples break the surface of the shingle which weakens their holding power.